The Supreme Court will make a landmark ruling about whether councils must factor in the long term climate impact when considering applications for fossil fuel production plants.
The Law Lords will hear the case of campaigner Sarah Finch who has been granted permission to appeal to the Supreme Court in her fight against the drilling of oil wells in Surrey.
Sarah believes the 2019 decision by Surrey County Council to allow wells to be drilled at Horse Hill, north east of Gatwick Airport, was unlawful because the “downstream” emissions from the proposed oil wells should have been factored into the Council’s Environmental Impact Assessment of the production of 3.3 million tonnes of oil to be produced by the wells over the next 20 years.
Court of Appeal judges were divided over the claim and their ruling in March 2022 means that at present other local councils can grant permissions for commercial fossil fuel production without the climate impact being part of an Environmental Impact Assessment.
Sarah believes the matter is of public importance and applied for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court for a final ruling on the case. Sarah now expects a hearing to take place during the course of next year.
Represented by law firm Leigh Day, Sarah’s argument will focus on the question of whether regulations 4 and 18 and paragraph 5 of Schedule 4 of the Environmental Impact Regulations require downstream emissions of fossil fuel development to be assessed, a matter that has not been considered by the Supreme Court or the House of Lords before.
At the Court of Appeal, Justice Moylan agreed that the failure to factor in “downstream” emissions produced through the commercial use of the oil to be extracted from the wells meant that the Environmental Impact Assessment did not comply with the regulations and was therefore unlawful.
However, two other judges held that it was ultimately a matter for the local planning authority to decide whether the “downstream” emissions were a significant effect of the development. They ruled that the reasons given by Surrey County Council for deciding that the downstream emissions were not an effect of the development, and therefore did not require assessment, were lawful.
Sarah has campaigned with the Weald Action Group and others against the proposed expansion of the Horse Hill Developments Ltd site, which would result in oil production well into the 2040s, perilously close to the Government’s 2050 target for Net Zero carbon emissions. It is estimated that the development could lead to more than 10 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent being released into the atmosphere when the oil is ultimately burned.
In granting permission to appeal, the Court of Appeal also awarded costs protection for Sarah Finch, in recognition of the importance of ensuring access to environmental justice under the United Nation’s Aarhus Convention, to which the UK is a signatory. Sarah Finch is grateful for the support of the Law for Change Fund.
Sarah Finch said:
“I’m delighted that I will get to take my case to the Supreme Court. The Court wouldn’t have granted permission if it didn’t think this was a very important legal issue which needs to be resolved.
“Granting planning permission for more oil extraction in the middle of a climate crisis without considering its full impact on our planet makes no sense and is, I believe, unlawful.
“If councils don’t assess all the climate impacts of a proposed development before giving it permission, then we have no chance whatever of staying within safe climate limits.”
Rowan Smith, Leigh Day environmental law solicitor who represents the campaigner, said:
“The Supreme Court’s very welcome decision to hear this matter is further proof that our client has been right to continue this long-running legal battle. At its heart, this case is about whether it is lawful for carbon emissions resulting from the use of oil to be completely ignored when permission is granted for that oil to be extracted. Our client has been clear throughout that, if that was allowed, then the whole system of environmental legal protection would be undermined. We look forward to presenting her case to the UK’s highest court.”
paxlovid buy: paxlovid 1st – Paxlovid buy online
cheaper http://rybelsus.tech/# rybelsus price
rybelsus.icu
pin up 306: pin up azerbaycan – pin up 306
https://1winci.icu/# пин ап вход
pin up
пин ап официальный сайт: пин ап официальный сайт – пинап зеркало
пин ап: пин ап – пин ап зеркало
пин ап зеркало: пин ап вход – пинап зеркало
1xbet скачать 1xbet скачать 1хбет
casino oyunlar?: h?zl? casino – dunyan?n en iyi casino siteleri
https://1winindia.tech/# пин ап казино
пинап
pin up casino: pin-up casino giris – pin up casino
пин ап пин ап официальный сайт пин ап вход
http://1winci.icu/# пин ап официальный сайт
пинап казино
пинап кз: пинап – pin up kz
casino sitesi: h?zl? casino – casino siteleri
pin up azerbaycan: pin up 306 – pin up casino
https://1wintr.fun/# canl? casino siteleri
пин ап казино вход
pin-up: pin up 306 – pinup az
canl? casino casino oyunlar? slot casino siteleri
1xbet скачать: 1xbet официальный сайт – 1xbet
пин ап казино: pin up kz – пинап казино
https://1winbrasil.win/# pinup az
пин ап казино вход
пин ап официальный сайт: пин ап – пин ап зеркало
пин ап официальный сайт пин ап зеркало пин ап официальный сайт
pin-up casino giris: pin up – pin up casino
http://1winbrasil.win/# pin-up casino giris
пинап кз
пин ап казино вход: пин ап – пин ап
pin-up: pinup az – pinup az
пин ап вход пин ап официальный сайт пин ап вход
пин ап официальный сайт: пин ап официальный сайт – пин ап зеркало
same-day delivery: buy gabapentin – buy gabapentin
buy amoxil online: Compare Prices – amoxil online
erection problems cheap medication anti fungal pills without prescription
india pharmacy mail order Indian pharmacy online online shopping pharmacy india
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
online canadian drugstore cheap pharmacy online how to fix ed
https://indianpharm24.pro/# indian pharmacy paypal
erection pills
mexico drug stores pharmacies Mexican pharmacy ship US mexican rx online
cheap erectile dysfunction pills online http://pharm24.pro/# legal to buy prescription drugs from canada
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexico pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican pharm 24 – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
https://indianpharm24.pro/# top 10 online pharmacy in india
ed pills that really work
top 10 pharmacies in india Indian pharmacy to USA Online medicine home delivery
natural ed https://indianpharm24.pro/# buy medicines online in india
buy prescription drugs without doctor cheap medication ed medications
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: mexican drugs – mexican drugstore online
http://pharm24.pro/# erectile dysfunction treatments
ed cures that actually work
medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican drugs – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
muse ed drug https://pharm24.pro/# erectile dysfunction remedies
best india pharmacy: Indian pharmacy online – online shopping pharmacy india
http://pharm24.pro/# mens erection pills
treatments for ed
best erectile dysfunction pills https://pharm24.pro/# ed treatment pills
indian pharmacies safe: indian pharm 24 – indian pharmacy online
http://mexicanpharm24.cheap/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
ed treatment pills
http://indianpharmacyeasy.com/# best india pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmgate.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico
https://mexicanpharmgate.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico
http://canadiandrugsgate.com/# cheap pills online
https://mexicanpharmgate.com/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
cat antibiotics without pet prescription: canadian pharmacy drugs gate – best ed treatments
amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription: canadiandrugsgate – canadian online pharmacy
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexicanpharmgate.com – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican drugstore online: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
buy cheap prescription drugs online: canadian pharmacy drugs gate – ed medications
http://canadiandrugsgate.com/# how can i order prescription drugs without a doctor
dapoxetine price: buy priligy – buy priligy max pharm
dapoxetine online: priligy maxpharm – buy dapoxetine online
amoxicillin buy online canada: can i buy amoxicillin over the counter in australia – amoxicillin 500 mg without a prescription
where can i get generic clomid without insurance cheap clomid can i get clomid price
where to buy clomid without insurance: generic clomid – cost clomid
priligy maxpharm: dapoxetine price – dapoxetine price
buy plavix: clopidogrel bisulfate 75 mg – antiplatelet drug
stromectol otc: iver fast – minocycline 50 mg tablets for human
buy cytotec pills online cheap: cyt premium – buy cytotec in usa
пинап казино: пинап казино – pinup-kazi.kz
vavada-kazi.ru: вавада казино зеркало – vavada kazi
пинап казино: пинап казино – pin up казино
пин ап казино: pinup-kazi.ru – пин ап казино
пинап казино: pinup-kazi.ru – pinup kazi
Online medicine home delivery: indian pharm – Online medicine order
world pharmacy india: IndianPharmStar – reputable indian pharmacies
ed meds online without doctor prescription: canadianpharm1st.com – prescription drugs without doctor approval
indian pharmacy online: indian pharm – Online medicine order
herbal ed remedies: canadianpharm1st – natural ed pills
male ed drugs: canada pharmacy online – injections for ed
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharm easy – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican rx online: MexicanPharmEasy – mexican drugstore online
https://paxlovid.ink/# Paxlovid.ink
https://gabapentinpharm.com/# Gabapentin Pharm
https://lisinoprilus.com/# prinivil 25 mg