A legal challenge has been issued regarding the UK Government’s lack of recognition for nonbinary people through the overseas route in the gender recognition certificate process.
Ryan Castellucci, who is nonbinary, has issued legal proceedings against the Gender Recognition Panel (GRP) and the Secretary of State for Justice arguing that the GRP breached its statutory duty to issue a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) in terms which record Ryan’s acquired gender as nonbinary, and has instead decided to issue a GRC of uncertain legal effect. Ryan is also seeking a declaration that a GRC which records Ryan’s gender as “not specified” would mean that their gender is for all purposes nonbinary.
A directions hearing has been listed before the High Court on 31 March 2022.
Ryan is an American citizen who moved to London under a Tier 1 Global Talent visa in 2019. They have obtained legal recognition of their gender in the US on all of their official US documents including their California birth certificate and passport. Ryan then sought to have their gender recognised in the UK through the Gender Recognition Act 2004.
The Gender Recognition Act states that a person can apply for a GRC on the basis of having changed their gender under the law of an approved country or territory outside the UK. California, along with most US states, is on the approved list of territories.
Ryan feels strongly that having a Gender Recognition Certificate which states their gender as nonbinary is the only way they can legally clarify their gender in this country.
Since Ryan’s claim was issued, the Minister for Women and Equalities, Kemi Badenoch MP, made a written ministerial statement on 9th January 2023 setting out the Government’s plans to update the list of approved countries and territories under the Gender Recognition Act. It is expected that this would end reciprocal recognition for trans people from most territories in the US, and countries such as Canada and New Zealand. The effect of this on Ryan’s application, should the Government go ahead with these plans, is unclear given Ryan’s only legally recognised gender is nonbinary.
Ryan’s reasons for bringing the claim
Ryan is bringing the claim to obtain legal validation of their gender in the UK, where they are living long-term and intend to make their permanent home.
Ryan says that the current UK approach to how their nonbinary identity is treated means that they are unable to regularise their administrative and legal affairs and ensure that they comply with the law, which is highly distressing.
For example, the UK Government website on biometric residence permits (BRP) states that “you must apply for a new BRP straight way” if one of a number of personal circumstances change, including gender. Ryan accordingly filled out the appropriate paperwork and marked ‘unspecified’ under gender as the only alternative to male or female. However, after lengthy correspondence with UK Visas and Immigration, Ryan received their BRP with female listed under gender, which is incorrect.
Ryan had similar difficulties applying for a provisional driving licence. While they were able to have ‘Mx” as their title the licence is still technically under female gender.
Difficulties also arose when Ryan had to undergo a background check for their job, which included a warning that providing false information was a criminal offence. Ryan contacted the relevant authority conducting the background to find out what they should put under gender as male/female were the only options. The person they spoke to did not know and ultimately Ryan wrote in nonbinary on the form; however, this was changed to female by the background check company without asking Ryan. While the check was successfully completed in the end, this caused Ryan significant anxiety that their professional life could be negatively affected by a legal and administrative failure to allow them to be recognised as nonbinary in the UK.
History of Ryan’s GRC application
Ryan’s GRC application was sent to the GRP in April 2022. The GRP initially stated that under the Gender Recognition Act “a person can only transition from either a Male to become a Female, or from Female to Male”, despite no such limitation in the text of the statute. The response then went on to ask Ryan to confirm that they would be “happy for the gender ‘Female’ to be printed on [their] gender recognition certificate”, since the original birth certificate listed ‘Male’. Ryan responded that they are not female, do not want to be certified as ‘Female’, and that since their acquired gender is nonbinary, this is what the Gender Recognition Act requires to be listed on their GRC.
Ryan received a further response from the Panel in September which stated that the GRP’s President had reviewed their query and that “the UK system is a binary system” and that “because of the way the computer programme is set up” the only options are ‘male’, ‘female’ or ‘not specified’. Ryan replied requesting further clarification of having ‘not specified’ printed on a GRC and whether this would mean a gender which cannot be classified as female or male.
A month later Ryan received a further reply from the President of the GRP confirming that she had granted their application on the basis that Ryan has been legally recognised as nonbinary in an approved territory, despite the fact that nonbinary is not a recognised gender in the UK. She confirmed that she could list ‘not specified’ on Ryan’s GRC but added that she was not able to confirm the legal effect of the ‘not specified’ category. She requested that Ryan make a decision on their GRC without any further correspondence or questions to the GRP team.
The legal proceedings
In principle, Ryan would be happy for their gender to be recorded as ‘not specified’ if the legal definition of that was that they are a gender that is not classified as male or female. However, Ryan does not feel they can accept a GRC with uncertain legal meaning.
A letter before action was sent to the President of the GRP and the Secretary of State by law firm Leigh Day, on Ryan’s behalf, on 7 November 2022 which requested that Ryan be issued a GRC which records their gender as nonbinary, or has an equivalent effect. A response to
the letter was not received and Ryan’s legal team issued proceedings in accordance with the time limits for an appeal to the GRP’s decision. The issued legal proceedings include:
– an application for judicial review on the grounds that the Panel breached its statutory duty to issue a GRC in terms which record Ryan’s acquired gender, and has instead decided to issue a GRC of uncertain legal effect;
– an application for a declaration that a GRC which records Ryan’s gender as “not specified” means that their gender is for all purposes nonbinary; and
– an appeal under the Gender Recognition Act on the ground that the Panel was wrong in law to reject Ryan’s application for a GRC that identifies Ryan as nonbinary.
Although having a GRC with nonbinary gender confirmed would not automatically mean that the Government has to recognise nonbinary for other documents, such as passports, Ryan feels it would be a positive and significant step forward in ensuring nonbinary people are properly, and legally, recognised in the UK.
Ryan Castellucci said:
“NHS England has over 100,000 people registered as “indeterminate” rather than female or male. The UK government has defined nonbinary people as those who “identify in some way outside of the man-woman gender binary”. Even so, they insist that allowing a person’s legal gender to be anything other than female or male would be too “complex”.
“My birth certificate and passport list my gender as “nonbinary” and “X” respectively. What then, as a matter of law, is my gender here in the UK? I don’t know, and the Government doesn’t seem to either. Every time it comes up they tell me that with my documents I may freely choose between female and male. They imply that there’s no wrong answer, but neither is right either. Sometimes I must fill out forms warning that giving dishonest answers is a criminal offence. By maintaining the status quo the Government has merely created a different complex situation rather than avoiding one.
“There are hundreds of thousands of transgender people living in the UK. They cannot change records of their birth, marriage, death, and taxes without a GRC. The process of getting one is so arduous that in the 2021/22 financial year only 800 applications were received. Going back to when the Gender Recognition Act (GRA) became law nearly 20 years ago, the total is still well under 10,000. Internationally, many other governments have begun allowing records to be changed with a sworn declaration. There’s no evidence of these streamlined processes being abused, yet the UK fighting this trend. I find this deeply disappointing.
“I read the GRA. I couldn’t find anything directly stating that male and female were the only options. It does, however, seem to explicitly say that I am entitled to a GRC matching my birth certificate. So I applied. My application was granted, yet my GRC has not been issued. They told me to choose an inaccurate gender or be left with a legally ambiguous gender. I cannot accept that.”
Kate Egerton, solicitor at law firm Leigh Day, added:
“Our client is simply asking for legal recognition of their acquired gender, as the Gender Recognition Act explicitly requires the GRP to provide. It is both unfair and illogical for someone who is legally recognised in one country as nonbinary to be forced to choose to be recognised as either male or female in the UK, or to be given a third ‘not specified’ option which has no legal meaning.”
Ryan has set up a crowdfunding campaign to offset the substantial costs of bringing this claim.
Plumbers Cheap offers comprehensive emergency plumbing services to meet all your residential and commercial needs. From leak repairs and pipe replacements to fixture installations and water heater maintenance, our experienced team delivers reliable solutions with a focus on quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction. Whether it’s routine maintenance or emergency repairs, Reliable Plumbers Cheap to keep your plumbing systems running smoothly.
https://biotpharm.com/# buy antibiotics
https://biotpharm.com/# buy antibiotics from canada
cheap ed drugs Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast
https://pharmau24.com/# Medications online Australia
Online medication store Australia: online pharmacy australia – Online drugstore Australia
over the counter antibiotics: Biot Pharm – over the counter antibiotics
Online drugstore Australia Online medication store Australia Online drugstore Australia
Medications online Australia: PharmAu24 – pharmacy online australia
Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast Ero Pharm Fast
https://biotpharm.shop/# Over the counter antibiotics for infection
pharmacy online australia: Buy medicine online Australia – pharmacy online australia
Pharm Au 24: pharmacy online australia – pharmacy online australia
https://eropharmfast.shop/# get ed prescription online
get antibiotics without seeing a doctor: Biot Pharm – buy antibiotics
pharmacy online australia: Online medication store Australia – Buy medicine online Australia
buy antibiotics from canada: BiotPharm – Over the counter antibiotics pills
http://biotpharm.com/# buy antibiotics for uti
buy antibiotics for uti: BiotPharm – get antibiotics quickly
cialis prix: Cialis generique sans ordonnance – Cialis pas cher livraison rapide
https://ciasansordonnance.shop/# Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
kamagra gel: acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance – kamagra en ligne
trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie: kamagra livraison 24h – commander Kamagra en ligne
commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription: traitement ED discret en ligne – cialis generique
acheter medicaments sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans prescription – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
http://kampascher.com/# kamagra livraison 24h
Acheter Cialis: cialis prix – commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription
Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance acheter Viagra sans ordonnance Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
acheter kamagra site fiable: trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie – kamagra pas cher
kamagra oral jelly: kamagra oral jelly – acheter kamagra site fiable
https://viasansordonnance.shop/# Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
Cialis generique sans ordonnance: Cialis generique sans ordonnance – acheter Cialis sans ordonnance
Viagra sans ordonnance 24h viagra sans ordonnance viagra en ligne
commander Viagra discretement: commander Viagra discretement – viagra en ligne
http://pharmsansordonnance.com/# acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
Viagra generique en pharmacie viagra en ligne Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance
cialis generique: acheter Cialis sans ordonnance – Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
pharmacie internet fiable France pharmacie en ligne pharmacie en ligne livraison europe
pharmacie internet fiable France: commander sans consultation medicale – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
where can i buy viagra over the counter usa: generic female viagra – viagra.com
viagra online price usa: VGR Sources – sildenafil 20 mg tablets cost
buy viagra price: VGR Sources – viagra online prescription
order sildenafil 100mg: VGR Sources – buy viagra us pharmacy
viagra triangle: VGR Sources – over the counter viagra 2017
best price for generic sildenafil: female viagra canada – how to buy viagra from canada
can i buy viagra over the counter canada VGR Sources viagra pills online uk
viagra uk where to buy: us over the counter viagra – can i buy viagra over the counter in india
generic viagra online canadian: viagra online rx pharmacy – order generic viagra uk
where can i get viagra over the counter VGR Sources sildenafil citrate 100
sildenafil 50mg: buy generic viagra in us – sildenafil tabs 20mg
https://vgrsources.com/# otc viagra usa
how much is viagra uk: VGR Sources – viagra soft tabs
drug prices sildenafil: buy brand viagra 100mg – viagra singapore over the counter
average cost of viagra pill best female viagra pills in india what is sildenafil
https://vgrsources.com/# lowest price viagra
25 mg generic viagra VGR Sources sildenafil online pharmacy india
where to purchase viagra: VGR Sources – buy cheap viagra online canada
how much is generic viagra where to buy cheap viagra in canada generic viagra quick delivery
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra paypal