The Competition Appeal Tribunal ruled on Tuesday that the opt-out collective action brought by Alex Neill Class Representative Limited against Sony over PlayStation digital content prices has failed, a claim totalling about £1.971 billion.
In its judgment ([2026] CAT 86, Case No 1527/7/7/22), the panel of Ben Tidswell (chair), Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard said: “We have concluded that the Class Representative has failed to establish that Sony has infringed competition law” [3].
The tribunal recorded that the class representative had not advanced a case on an alternative market definition [3]. It said it had also tried to record, at least in outline, its views on other issues raised by the claim [3].
The class comprises approximately 12.2 million consumers who made UK purchases of digital content on PlayStation consoles between 19 August 2016 (England and Wales) or 19 August 2017 (Scotland) and 12 February [1].
The defendants are Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Limited and Sony Interactive Entertainment Network Europe Limited, subsidiaries in the Sony group [2].
The claim was brought under s.18 of the Competition Act 1998 and, before 31 December 2020, Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. It alleged abuse of dominant positions causing higher prices [5].
The class representative alleged dominance in a primary console market, aftermarkets for PlayStation system software, and markets for the digital distribution of games and of add-on content, each limited to the UK [6], [7].
The alleged abuses were exclusive dealing, tying of the PlayStation Store, refusal to supply, and excessive and unfair pricing [8].
The class representative said that, without the exclusionary abuses, prices of content sold by third parties and by Sony would have been about 20% lower. It said the same of the exploitative pricing abuse [9], [10].
It sought approximately £1.490 billion in damages plus simple interest of 8% a year, giving a total claim of about £1.971 billion [11].
The proceedings were first filed on 22 August 2022 and certified on 21 November 2023 [16]. The trial ran for ten weeks between March and May, with the hearing at Salisbury Square House between 10 March and 8 May [16].
The Competition and Markets Authority intervened under r.50(2) of the Competition Appeal Tribunal Rules 2015, filing written observations dated 9 July 2025 on aspects of the law [12]. Sony responded on 12 September 2025 and the CMA replied on 6 October 2025 [13].
In a letter of 23 January the CMA said it agreed with the approach taken in Kent v Apple [2025] CAT 67 [14]. The tribunal said it found the CMA’s observations, and Sony’s in response, helpful [15].
Sony called 12 factual witnesses, all cross-examined by the class representative’s counsel. The class representative called none [21], [22].
The parties relied on 14 expert reports, and the tribunal referred to Practice Direction 2/25 (Expert Evidence) of 2 December 2025 in managing that evidence [19].
The tribunal recorded Sony’s evidence that it sells PlayStation consoles at low or negative profitability and recovers value through later sales of games, add-on content and services [48], [49]. For digital games, Sony first agrees a wholesale price with publishers and then sets the retail price on the PlayStation Store [68].
The tribunal also noted correspondence from the class representative saying that on 1 July Sony had announced changes to new PlayStation physical game releases from January 2028 [73].
McLean, instructed by Milberg London LLP, appeared for the class representative.

