Skip to content
Sunday 22 November 2026
Law News
Law News

Ninth Circuit sends Washington Yakima Valley voting case back to district court in light of Callais

Exterior of a federal courthouse building

The Ninth Circuit sends the Yakima Valley Voting Rights Act case back to the district court for proceedings consistent with the Callais decision.

Sources2 documents

The Ninth Circuit on Thursday remanded Palmer v. Trevino, the Yakima Valley Voting Rights Act case, to the district court for proceedings consistent with Louisiana v. Callais.

The three-judge panel of McKeown, Gould and Owens, circuit judges, issued the order on remand from the Supreme Court, and denied a motion for supplemental briefing.

The panel acted in view of the Supreme Court’s remand in Trevino v. Hobbs, No. 25-918, on 5 October. It said it was remanding “to the district court for proceedings consistent with Louisiana v. Callais, 608 U.S. 85 (2026)”.

The appellees’ motion to set a schedule for supplemental briefing was denied. The order gives no reasons.

The plaintiffs are Latino voters from Washington’s Yakima Valley who sued the State of Washington and the Secretary of State, Steven Hobbs. They alleged that the configuration of Legislative District 15 diluted Latino voting strength, in violation of Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.

Jose Trevino, Ismael Campos and Alex Ybarra were permitted to intervene to oppose the Section 2 claim. After a bench trial, the district court entered judgment for the plaintiffs on 10 August 2023.

The State did not enact a remedial map in the time allowed, and on 15 March 2024 the district court adopted a court-drawn map, Remedial Map 3B. The State accepted it and did not appeal. The intervenors did.

In a published decision on 27 August 2025, the Ninth Circuit held that the district court had jurisdiction without a three-judge court. It held that the intervenors lacked Article III standing to appeal the Section 2 liability determination or to challenge the remedial map under Section 2.

It also held that Trevino had standing to bring an equal protection challenge to the remedial map, but rejected that challenge, concluding that race was not the predominant factor in the remedial map-drawing process.

The Supreme Court decided Louisiana v. Callais on 29 April. Trevino and Ybarra, whose certiorari petition was then pending, went back to the district court and sought relief from the liability and remedial orders under Rule 60(b). They also asked it to reinstate the 2021 legislative map adopted by the Washington State Redistricting Commission.

Judge Robert Lasnik denied the motion on 15 May on a threshold ground. He held that the intervenors had not established standing to seek the relief. “Rule 60(b) does not dispense with Article III’s requirements,” he wrote.

He treated the Ninth Circuit’s ruling as binding. “Unless and until the Supreme Court grants review and disturbs that judgment, the Ninth Circuit’s Article III ruling is the law of the case and binds this Court on remand,” the order said.

The plaintiffs, the Secretary of State and the State each opposed the motion. The State acknowledged that Callais substantially altered Section 2 law and anticipated that the district court or the Ninth Circuit might need to apply it to this case. It argued that relief should be refused less than three months before the August primary.

Hobbs took no position on whether Callais affects the earlier orders. He opposed any change to the legislative districts for the 2026 elections, saying that candidate-filing and precinct-boundary deadlines had passed.

The case returns to Judge Lasnik in the Western District of Washington, No. 3:22-cv-05035.