Olivia and Brooke Huss, aged 10 and 12, were charged under Pennsylvania crime code 3304, the criminal mischief provision, which requires proof of intent. The judge found that element was not met and returned a not-guilty verdict.
What Happened at Veterans Memorial Park
The incident occurred on 21 May at Veterans Memorial Park in Springdale. Olivia, Brooke, and several other children twisted the chains of a playground swing so it would spin them around, a common enough playground activity. The swing broke.
TribLive reports that the total repair bill came to approximately $295, which Springdale Borough divided among five children it considered responsible, at roughly $59 each.
Three of the five families paid their share without contest. Katie Huss, the girls’ mother, refused. She asked the borough for proof that her daughters had caused the damage intentionally before she would settle, according to CBS News Pittsburgh. That refusal prompted the borough to pursue the matter through the courts.
Huss has said her concern was never primarily about the money. Her objection was to the way Springdale Borough and police conducted themselves throughout: she was not shown the surveillance footage or any other evidence before the court hearing took place.
The Springdale Borough Swing Charges and the Intent Threshold
The legal difficulty for the prosecution was always the intent element. Criminal mischief under Pennsylvania law is not made out by mere carelessness or rough play; the code section under which the girls were charged requires the prosecution to establish that the defendant intentionally damaged property.
A judge found that the girls had, in fact, caused the swing to break. The acquittal turned on the distinction between causing damage and intending it, and on that question the prosecution fell short.
Huss told reporters that five or six children had been involved in the incident, yet police concentrated their attention on her daughters. The reason for that focus has not been publicly explained by Springdale Borough or its police department.
A Borough’s Handling Under Scrutiny
PennLive reported the not-guilty finding on 20 August, and the case has drawn wider attention since. For Huss, the verdict vindicated her daughters, but the process itself remains her grievance.
The borough proceeded to criminal charges against children aged 10 and 12 over a broken swing worth approximately $295 in repairs, without, on her account, providing the family with the evidence before the hearing. Whether Springdale Borough reviews its own procedures in light of the outcome is the question the verdict leaves open.

