31.5 C
London
HomeLegal NewsCourt of Appeal to determine whether Microsoft missed court filing deadline with...

Court of Appeal to determine whether Microsoft missed court filing deadline with submission filed electronically at 4:52pm

  • Procedural point of practical importance to all legal practitioners engaged in commercial litigation
  • Vice-President of the Court of Appeal has directed that the question as to whether the correct filing time is 4:30pm or 23:59pm shall be determined at an oral hearing.

London, 22 August 2022: ValueLicensing, a UK-based preowned software licence reseller, announced that a date has now been set by the Court of Appeal for 9 November for an oral hearing to consider the issue of the correct filing time under the procedural rules applying to commercial litigation.

This unusual situation arose after lawyers for Microsoft filed documents requesting permission to appeal electronically at 4:52pm on 6 June 2022, via the Electronic Working Scheme (known as CE File), which is mandatory. Microsoft is the defendant in a standalone High Court damages claim brought by ValueLiensing in April 2021 alleging that the Seattle-based multinational abused its dominant position when it engaged in conduct that eliminated the vast majority of preowned software licences from the market.

ValueLicensing’s position is that Microsoft’s deadline for filing the documents in question in the Court of Appeal on 6 June 2022 was 4:30pm, and that its filing was therefore made 22 minutes late, based on paragraph D18.2 of the Commercial Court Guide which states:

If the Court orders that an Act be done by a certain date without specifying a time for compliance, the latest time for compliance is 4:30pm on the day in question.

In an Order dated 29 June 2022, Master Bancroft-Rimmer of the Civil Appeals Office took the view that the Commercial Court Guide does not apply to the Court of Appeal and that therefore Microsoft’s documents were lodged on time because it could file anytime up to 23:59pm when using CE File.

ValueLicensing then requested a review of that decision in view of the practical importance for all lawyers engaged in commercial litigation in the courts in England and Wales. The Vice-President of the Court of Appeal subsequently directed that ValueLicensing’s request for reconsideration should be determined at an oral hearing.

Jonathan Horley, founder and Managing Director of ValueLicensing said: “We are pleased that this procedural question is going to be thoroughly aired and determined by a Court of Appeal judge. When we saw that Microsoft had filed its documents 22 minutes after 4:30pm, we felt that it was important to point out that on our interpretation of the procedural rules, that filing was late. Barristers and solicitors who engage with the Commercial Court and the Appeal Court will no doubt be closely monitoring the outcome, given the important practical implications for their day-to-day practice.”

Further information about ValueLicensing’s claim against Microsoft can be found on the plaintiff’s Blog. On 3 August, ValueLicensing consented to Microsoft being given an extension until 30 September 2022 to file its defence in the High Court.

latest articles

explore more

17 COMMENTS

  1. As a new game bird, splitting its content into online and in-person events. Make a choice wisely before you commence your game play at 888Ladies, and The Wynn oozes class right from the front door. The slot features a beautiful background with the Florence Cathedral, theres nothing to worry about. If your last transaction was a free bonus, need make a deposit before claiming this coupon code or your winnings will be unavailable and you will cant cash out. As a new game bird, splitting its content into online and in-person events. Make a choice wisely before you commence your game play at 888Ladies, and The Wynn oozes class right from the front door. The slot features a beautiful background with the Florence Cathedral, theres nothing to worry about. If you are looking for the best casino promotions online, consider visiting Gossip Slots Casino. This casino offers some of the top bonuses and promotions. You can claim the Gossip Slots bonuses as soon as you create a real money account and make your first deposit. You simply have to continue making deposits to be eligible to claim the bonuses.
    https://rac.thairobotics.org/2025/05/27/why-aviator-game-isnt-just-redundant-a-review-for-kenyan-players/
    Matej and the rest of the team go truly in-depth with each online casino they evaluate. They check each casino’s website, thoroughly read the Terms and Conditions to uncover and unfair rules, evaluate player complaints, check licenses and company information, and go through countless other steps required to learn everything we need to know to evaluate an online casino and decide whether we are going to recommend it to our visitors or not. Based on this, we calculate each casino’s Safety Index and decide which online casinos to recommend and which not to recommend. These are examples of actual complaints received by the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA). If you’re in a situation like these, you probably won’t see your money again.

  2. Dos Badniks Robot Butterflies (uno en buen estado y otro roto) en Sonic the Hedgehog CD. ¡Inspírate para tu viaje a Liberec con nuestros itinerarios seleccionados, llenos de atracciones populares todos los días! ¡Consúltalos aquí! JUGAR CON RESPONSABILIDAD: luckyjet-games es un sitio web independiente sin vínculos con los sitios web que promocionamos. Antes de participar en cualquier tipo de juego, asegúrate de que cumples todos los requisitos legales y los criterios de edad de tu jurisdicción. Nuestra misión aquí en luckyjetgames es proporcionar contenido informativo y de entretenimiento con fines puramente educativos – si hace clic en estos enlaces externos, saldrá de este sitio por completo. lucky jet играть 1win-luckyjet-game.ru . Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
    https://inceltourism.com/resena-del-juego-balloon-de-smartsoft-por-que-es-uno-de-los-mas-descargados-en-chile/
    Para descargar Lucky Jet Predictor para Android, sigue los pasos que se indican a continuación: Además de 1Win Aviator, la plataforma incluye otros títulos en tendencia para ganar dinero rápido. Los juegos instantaneos son populares por su gran diversión y multiplicadores de ganancias que aseguran un premio justo. Los títulos disponibles son: Ingresar dinero en tu cuenta de casino en 1Win es un proceso sencillo y rápido que se puede completar en menos de cinco clics. No importa desde qué país visites el sitio web de 1Win, el proceso es siempre el mismo o muy similar. Con solo seguir unos pocos pasos, podrás ingresar el dinero deseado en tu cuenta y comenzar a disfrutar de los juegos y apuestas que 1Win tiene para ofrecer. El bot está en el dominio público. El usuario solo necesita encontrar el archivo de instalación a través de la barra de búsqueda de su propio navegador de Internet. Una opción podría ser escribir – Telegram bot señales de Lucky Jet. Después de eso, es necesario encontrar el canal adecuado y aplicar para unirse. Automáticamente, el dispositivo móvil notificará al dueño del nuevo pronóstico. Las noticias llegan sin demora. No existe un pago por descargar, instalar o mantener el bot de Lucky Jet.

  3. It?¦s really a great and useful piece of info. I?¦m happy that you simply shared this useful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

  4. This online casino has established itself as one of the top casinos in the industry. It offers a diverse selection of games, including JetX. The casino is licensed by both the Malta Gaming Authority and Curacao eGaming. Written by: Michael Shackleford Unibet Casino is a trusted and well-known online casino that offers a great selection of games and features. The casino is licensed by the Malta Gaming Authority and uses the latest security technology to protect its players. Unibet Casino also has a strong commitment to responsible gaming and offers a number of tools to help its players stay in control. JetX Casino Game Since its debut in 2018, crash games have surged in popularity, surpassing traditional gaming choices. SmartSoft Gaming leads the charge in this arena, developing innovative solutions like JetX. JetX blends skill, strategy, and luck, offering boundless excitement and top-notch quality. Gotsadze targets mobile and video gaming enthusiasts, aiming to enter markets with a robust gaming culture, initially prioritizing regions craving dynamic content.
    https://yeswiki.hainaut.be/PAEDC/?tranverpedest1973
    You can withdraw your money at any time to your account like Jazecah, Easypisa, or any bank account that you are using. When you withdraw your money to your any account you can receive your money within one working day. To deposit money to this app is very simple you just have to connect your Jazecash or Easypisa account and click on the amount that you want to deposit to your account. It takes a few minutes to successfully deposit to your account. I love how Indiluck combines fun and strategy. The seamless gameplay and consistent winnings keep me coming back. So explore and enjoy multi-diversity by downloading Jhandi Munda King APK. Yes, the S9 Teen Patti is real and you can invest money in this application without any doubt today many people earn money by using this application. This game works on Android versions and enables players to deposit funds to double the money. If you want to make money by playing simple to unique card games, download the app available on this website.

  5. At Wonna, we focus on delivering high-odds betting predictions. Our proven strategies are designed to keep you engaged and excited, providing you with a thrilling betting experience. Whether you’re looking for long-shot opportunities or more conservative bets, our high-odds tips will enhance your betting strategy. Granie w grę demo Aviator wiąże się z kilkoma oczekiwanymi korzyściami, z których niektóre warto rozważyć. Oto spojrzenie na zwykłe i niezwykłe wyniki: An anonymized string created from your email address (also called a hash) may be provided to the Gravatar service to see if you are using it. The Gravatar service privacy policy is available here: automattic privacy . After approval of your comment, your profile picture is visible to the public in the context of your comment.
    http://dayawane.ihep.ac.cn/twiki/bin/view/Public/ShawnaRobinson
    Gra Aviator oferuje kilka form bonusów, w tym darmowe spiny i zakłady automatyczne. Dodatkowo w grze dostępny jest czat, który umożliwia graczom interakcję i dzielenie się wskazówkami w kasynie aviator w sekcji gier awaryjnych. Powodzenie 20Bet kasyno opiera się również na współpracy wraz z znakomitymi dostawcami gier, jakie możliwości umożliwia najwyższą jakość batalii. Wśród partnerów kasyna znajdują się tego… Location:Murrintown , Wexford Istnieją również bardziej unikalne opcje nagród. Pin-Up oferuje 30 darmowych spinów bez depozytu za potwierdzenie numeru telefonu i adresu e-mail. Możesz wykonać te manipulacje na swoim koncie osobistym za pomocą odpowiednich przycisków. Muszą być również spełnione dwa warunki: Niezależnie od tego, czy jesteś nowicjuszem w grze Aviator, czy też chcesz spędzić trochę czasu grając w nią za darmo bez ryzykowania pieniędzy, tryb demo jest najlepszym rozwiązaniem. Będziesz mógł zapoznać się z interfejsem i wszystkimi funkcjami. Co więcej, gracze mogą również pracować nad podstawowymi strategiami, które chcą wykorzystać podczas sesji na prawdziwe pieniądze. Niektóre z korzyści wypróbowania gry samolotowej Aviator za darmo obejmują:

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here