Skip to content
Sunday 22 November 2026
Law News
Law News

Fifth Circuit Strikes Down Federal Interstate Handgun Sales Ban

interstate handgun sales ban

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has struck down the federal interstate handgun sales ban in a 2–1 ruling, holding that the prohibition on direct handgun purchases by out-of-state buyers from licensed dealers violates the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution.

The decision in Elite Precision Customs L.L.C. v. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives was authored by Judge Jerry Smith and joined by Judge Kurt Engelhardt. Judge Catharina Haynes dissented, stating she agreed with the district court’s decision upholding the law.

What the Federal Interstate Handgun Sales Ban Requires

Under the statutory framework the Fifth Circuit has now struck down, prospective purchasers wishing to buy a handgun from an out-of-state dealer are required by 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(3) and (b)(3) to have the firearm first transferred through a federally licensed dealer in their home state. The buyer bears the cost of that intermediary transaction, typically a transfer fee charged by the receiving dealer.

The panel held that this regime, even where technically circumventable, imposes an unconstitutional burden on the exercise of a fundamental right. ‘Even to the extent that the Ban can be circumvented by the licensee-to-licensee transfer workaround (which vests full veto power over interstate handgun sales in a group of third parties financially dependent on the government’s licensing regime), the Ban invariably calls for the payment of a fee over and above the cost of a handgun,’ the opinion states.

The panel added: ‘We must pause before endorsing a cost attached to the exercise of a fundamental constitutional right.’

Bruen’s Role in the Interstate Handgun Sales Ban Challenge

The majority’s reasoning turns squarely on the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen, which replaced interest-balancing with a text, history, and tradition framework for Second Amendment analysis.

The Fifth Circuit had previously declined to invalidate the same prohibition in Mance v. Sessions in 2018, applying what the panel now characterises as a superseded pre-Bruen standard. The majority explicitly rejected the argument, echoing language from Mance, that the ban represents only a minor infringement because it still ‘allow[s] ample access to handguns by those who are permitted to possess and purchase them under state and local laws.’

The denial of en banc rehearing in Mance had itself drawn a dissent from seven judges, including Judges Jones, Smith, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt, and Elrod, who favoured adopting precisely the text, history, and tradition approach that Bruen subsequently mandated. The composition of that dissent, which included both judges in the present majority, is relevant context for the panel’s willingness to depart from the earlier ruling.

The majority was explicit that prior Fifth Circuit decisions suggesting some costs on Second Amendment rights are permissible are now abrogated: ‘To the extent that prior decisions from this court hint there is an acceptable cost that may be imposed on the basic exercise of Second Amendment rights, they are abrogated by Bruen and its progeny.’

Representation and Broader Significance

The plaintiffs were represented by David H. Thompson, Peter A. Patterson, and William V. Bergstrom of Cooper and Kirk PLLC, together with Cody J. Wisniewski of FPC Action Foundation. The case is part of a broader litigation campaign being pursued by the Firearms Policy Coalition to challenge federal firearms restrictions in the wake of Bruen.

Reports on the ruling confirm the panel held that federal laws blocking a direct handgun sale to an out-of-state buyer are constitutionally indefensible under the post-Bruen framework. The Firearm Blog similarly characterised the decision as striking down the federal ban in its entirety rather than on narrow grounds.

Judge Haynes’s dissent, aligned with the district court below, represents the position that the existing federal framework is constitutionally defensible. Subject to any onward appeal, the ruling creates a circuit precedent invalidating the interstate handgun sales ban, and the government will need to decide whether to seek en banc review by the full Fifth Circuit or petition the Supreme Court, a decision that could determine whether the ruling remains confined to the Fifth Circuit or forces a nationwide resolution of the question.